top of page

Immigrant Rights Advocates React to the Trump Shutdown

Await reason to return to congress and solutions to replace fear

President Donald Trump has made good on his promise to shut down the government if the new budget lacked funding for a border wall. While some are disappointed that many federal employees will be furloughed through the holidays (Border Patrol and Homeland Security agents ironically among them), advocates for immigrant rights are relieved that so many U.S. Senators did not bow to Trump’s demand.

“It’s unfortunate that the president and Congress can’t come to a sensible agreement that the majority of people accept,” said Michigan United Legal Services Director Diego Bonesetti. "But think more funding, given the abusive way in which this administration wields its power, would only have made things worse.”

Bonesetti notes that America has seen an influx of refugees many times in recent history, such as Vietnamese ‘boat people’ and the Mariel boatlift of Cubans. But the difference this time is the American response. Instead of directing resources to helping people, the Trump Administration is “slow walking” access to asylum.

“Where they normally should have 100 credible fear interviews a day, they were running 40 to 80 a day," Bonesetti said. "Instead of bringing personnel from other parts of the country to increase capacity to process these applications, they’ve frustrated people until they say 'I’ll just go to the border, turn myself in and then they’ll have to take my application.'"

Justice For Our Neighbors Legal Director Melanie Goldberg has seen the asylum process through the eyes of migrants who she has served.

“They don’t know our immigration laws. They don’t know our asylum system. What they know is that they fear for their lives and are trying to come to a place where they and their families can be safer.”

Goldberg says the movement of people from dangerous situations is not new or unique. She thinks the $5 billion would be better allocated to agencies that see the cases through, such as USCIS and the immigration court system.

“I look forward to the sensitive and sensible actions of the next congress. I hope that when they tackle immigration reform they remain true to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights which states ‘Everyone has the right to seek and enjoy asylum from persecution’.”

“Everybody knows a border wall is ineffective, expensive and a major environmental hazard,” said Oscar Castañeda, Chariman of the Civil Rights for Immigrants Task Force at Action Greater Lansing. “This administration keeps sabotaging the political process of the country, despite the fact that Americans seem to be growing friendlier to foreigners.”

This year Gallup and the Pew Research Center reported that a record 75% of them think that immigration is good for the country, up from 66% in 2012.

“Despite all the negative narrative and dog whistle messages, Americans still think that immigration is a good thing,” Castañeda said. “We need to be consistent, we need to be clear and we need to be in communication with our representatives and remind them that they have control now and they can help put pressure in this situation.


bottom of page